Le rapport d’Ahmad Jaradat, membre de la Fondation Frantz Fanon, Born into an uncertain future: Palestinian children in occupied Jerusalem, se centre sur la vie des enfants de Jérusalem-est occupée et des violations multiples auxquelles ils sont confrontés dans leur vie quotidienne.
Ces violations sont commises dans un silence absolu. Les jeunes Palestiniens sont abandonnés, aussi bien par nombre de ceux qui défendent les droits humains que par les Etats se présentant comme les héritiers de ceux qui ont pensé la théorie des droits humains. Comment la communauté internationale peut-elle regarder ces enfants se faire tuer, être blessés, mis en prison sans aucune preuve, privés de leur vie d’enfant ? Comment assume t-elle le spectacle de ces jeunes assistant impuissants à la démolition de leur maison, de leur école ou fuyant devant les colons qui viennent voler leurs terres sous le regard amusé de l’armée israélienne ?
Ce qui se passe à Jérusalem-est se passe aussi à Hébron, d’où les observateurs internationaux viennent d’être expulsés après 25 ans passés à témoigner des violations des droits humains et des conditions de vie violant l’ensemble des droits fondamentaux des Palestiniens, dont une majorité de jeunes.
Aucun des Etats constituant la communauté internationale ne peut ignorer, face à tous ces crimes de guerre commis par l’Etat israélien, au regard de la 4me Convention de Genève, que tous ces actes «internationalement illicites, engagent la responsabilité internationale de l’Etat». Il faut sans cesse rappeler ce que la communauté internationale oublie, et qui avait été très clairement énoncé par la Cour Internationale de Justice, dans son avis consultatif à propos du mur, à savoir que l’Etat d’Israël a violé et viole diverses obligations internationales. Il s’agit en conséquence d’un comportement illicite qui relève typiquement d’un acte internationalement illicite. De ce fait, il s’ensuit que, selon le droit international, la responsabilité de cet Etat est engagée. La CIJ rappelle aussi que l’Etat d’Israël a mené une politique et développé des pratiques consistant à établir des colonies de peuplement dans le territoire palestinien occupé. Notons que, dans le cas du peuple palestinien et par rapport à l’acte internationalement illicite israélien, sont en cause des obligations considérées comme « essentielles » pour la «communauté internationale tout entière».
ici qu’en 1970, dans un arrêt célèbre, la
Cour internationale de Justice avait précisé qu’ «une distinction essentielle
doit être établie entre les obligations des Etats envers la communauté
internationale dans son ensemble et celles qui naissent vis-à-vis d’un autre
Etat …. Par leur nature même,
les premières concernent tous les Etats. Vu l’importance des droits en cause,
tous les Etats peuvent être considérés comme ayant un intérêt juridique à ce
que ces droits soient protégés ; les obligations dont il s’agit sont des
obligations erga omnes » qui découlent « de la mise hors la loi des actes d’agression et du génocide mais
aussi des principes et des règles concernant les droits fondamentaux de
la personne humaine, y compris la protection contre la discrimination
raciale. (…) Certains droits de protection correspondants se sont intégrés au
droit international général, d’autres sont conférés par des instruments
internationaux à caractère universel ou quasi universel ». Tous les Etats
connaissent pertinemment les éléments constituant un fait illicite et savent
très bien qu’ils sont commis depuis plus de soixante dix ans par l’Etat
d’Israël et cela en toute impunité. Les enfants sont les premières victimes des
violations des droits fondamentaux de la personne humaine. Et pourtant la
communauté internationale et la majorité des gouvernements des Etats
constituant cette communauté, ne cessent de parler quand il s’agit du climat et
de l’environnement que des décisions drastiques doivent être prises pour
préserver les enfants et les générations futures ! Les enfants
palestiniens en seraient ils exclus ?
 Senior officer, Alternatice Information Centre, AIC
 Hebron monitors: aid organizations raise the alarm at increased risks to civilians ; publié le 14 février 2019 ; https://www.oxfam.org/en/pressroom/pressreleases/2019-02-13/hebron-monitors-aid-organisations-raise-alarm-increased-risks
 larticle 1 du projet de Code sur la responsabilité internationale de l’Etat
 CIJ, Conséquences juridiques de l’édification d’un mur dans le territoire palestinien occupé, AC, 19 juillet 2004, § 143.
 CIJ, Conséquences juridiques de l’édification d’un mur dans le territoire palestinien occupé, AC, 19 juillet 2004, § 145.
 CIJ, Conséquences juridiques de l’édification d’un mur dans le territoire palestinien occupé, AC, 19 juillet 2004, § 147.
 CIJ, Conséquences juridiques de l’édification d’un mur dans le territoire palestinien occupé, AC, 19 juillet 2004, § 120.
 CIJ, Arrêt Barcelona Traction, Recueil, 1970.
 CIJ, Arrêt Barcelona Traction, Recueil, 1970, § 33.
 L’affaire du tramway de Jérusalem au regard du droit international : une affaire symbolique ou une question de responsabilité internationale de l’Etat français ? Mireille Fanon Mendès France ; Revue d’études palestiniennes n° 98 ; 2006 ISBN : 9782707319494
Born into an uncertain future: Palestinian children in occupied Jerusalem
The next generation of Palestinians in the holy city faces a web of discriminatory and violent Israeli policies.
In Jerusalem, Palestinians suffer from a web of institutional, personal, violent and quotidian forms of discrimination due to the Israeli colonial occupation. Yet, the Palestinian population in Jerusalem continues to grow. The Palestinian population in the holy city has increased fivefold since 1967 and now constitutes at least 38 percent of the city. In addition to posing a formidable challenge to the Israeli occupation, the Palestinian population’s increase means that more Palestinian children are growing up under a protracted military occupation. To understand the urgency with which the international community must act to end the Israeli occupation, one must grasp the discriminatory and violent policies that shape the lives and futures of Palestinian children in the holy city from the moment they are born.
The status of Jerusalem
The United Nations (UN) 1947 Partition Plan for Palestine declared Jerusalem a “corpus separatum,” meaning as an international city that would be administered by the UN. However, in 1948, Zionist paramilitaries and Israeli forces captured West Jerusalem and 40 nearby Palestinian villages, along with 78 percent of Historic Palestine. Palestinians call this event the Nakba, meaning “catastrophe.” During the Nakba between 750,000 and one million Palestinians were expelled from their homes, including between 64,000 and 80,000 in the Jerusalem area.
After the 1948 war, Jerusalem was divided into east and west. The Israeli army controlled 85 percent of the city in the west; the Jordanian army controlled eleven percent of the city in the east; the remaining four percent was designated as “no man’s land”. In 1967, Israel captured the remaining 15 percent of Jerusalem and expelled another 26,000 Palestinians from the city. Israeli authorities quickly implemented policies to institutionalize the military occupation and establish a Jewish majority in Jerusalem.
Israel formalized its 1967 annexation of East Jerusalem in 1980 when it passed Basic Law: Jerusalem, Capital of Israel. In December 2017, U.S. President Donald Trump legitimized the annexation too when he recognized Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. The international community affirms Jerusalem’s Palestinian residents as protected under the Fourth Geneva Convention. The UN Security Council maintains that all legislative measures and actions taken by Israel to alter the character and status of Jerusalem are null and void under UN resolutions 242, 267, 471, 476, 478.
Born without papers
Palestinian children who live in Jerusalem are not born with a right to live in their hometowns. Since 1967, Palestinians in East Jerusalem have lived as “permanent residents” – an Israeli legal status that makes their presence a revocable privilege, rather than an inherent right.
Permanent residency status is not automatically transferred through marriage or on to the holder’s children. Instead, around the time when Palestinian children enter high school, they are required to present themselves to Israeli authorities and supply proof that Jerusalem is at the center of their life according to the “center of life” policy. The “center of life” policy stipulates that if a Palestinian cannot prove that her everyday life revolves around Jerusalem then she will lose her residency rights to the city and be evicted to the West Bank. Even if a Palestinian can meet this strict standard, Israeli authorities retain the power to revoke her residency rights at any time. Between 1967 and 2016, Israel revoked the status of at least 14,595 Palestinians from East Jerusalem, according to the Interior Ministry.
In Jerusalem, multiple kinds of schools are available to Palestinian children, though all of them except the Israeli schools are severely under resourced. Palestinian families tend to prefer to keep children in Jerusalem schools, as opposed to schools in the West Bank, to ensure that their children have a chance at obtaining permanent Jerusalem residency status under the “center of life” policy.
Resident of Jerusalem and political analyst Rassem Obaidat summarized the issues facing Palestinian schoolchildren : « In Jerusalem we face many problems regarding the education system, mainly in elementary schools. First, there is the issue of overcrowding in schools that are overseen by the Palestinian Education Ministry. Second, the areas where the schools are located are already crowded and the Israeli occupation refuses to issue construction permits to expand the schools. Finally, Israeli authorities continue to change the political aspects of the curriculum by censoring everything related to Palestinian national identity. »
Types of schools
Palestinian Jerusalemites can attend Israeli municipal schools overseen by the Israeli ministry of education, which supplies curriculum that hostile to Palestinian identity and critiques of Israeli colonialism. Secondly, Palestinian children may attend schools overseen by the Islamic Waqf, which uses curriculum supplied by the Palestinian Authority (PA) Ministry of Education. In Shuafat Refugee Camp, Palestinian children attend schools run by UNRWA, which also teach the PA curriculum, though Israeli authorities have recently threatened to shut down these schools. Finally, there are some private schools in the area, which attain financial support from donations, tuition and sometimes the Israeli municipality.
Lack of resources
Palestinian children in Jerusalem suffer from a lack of classrooms and inadequate classrooms. According to Israeli human rights group Ir Amim, there is a shortage of around 2,000 classrooms in East Jerusalem. According to the United Nations Development Program (UNDP), around 43 percent of existing classrooms are inadequate due to overcrowding and poor infrastructure. Israeli authorities maintain a discriminatory zoning regime in East Jerusalem that almost outlaws Palestinian residential construction of all kind in the area. Consequently, Palestinian schools cannot expand to account for the deficit in classrooms.
Drop out rates
Jerusalem schools that serve Palestinian children have extremely high rates of students dropping out. According to Ir Amim, the dropout rate for schools in East Jerusalem has reached 33 percent. The UNDP points out that inadequate infrastructure for schools and classrooms leads to high drop-out rates.
Ir Amim reports that around 17,000 children, or around 13 percent of all children in East Jerusalem, are not registered in a known educational institution.
In the last five years, Israel has demolished 785 Palestinian-owned structures in Jerusalem. Many Palestinian children are made homeless by these demolitions, as typically entire families are abruptly displaced and fined thousands of dollars for “illegal” construction.
Israel demolishes most Palestinian-owned property in Jerusalem under the pretext that the structures were built illegally, meaning without Israeli-issued construction permits. However, Israeli authorities almost exclusively issue construction permits to Israeli Jewish neighborhoods and settlements. This is because the city has not approved an urban plan for East Jerusalem and zones only 8 to 13 percent of the area as for Palestinian residential construction. As a result, Palestinians build without permits to avoid overcrowding. The Association for Civil Rights in Israel found that 20,000 homes in East Jerusalem – or 39 percent of all homes in East Jerusalem – lack Israeli construction permits and therefore live in perpetual threat of abrupt homelessness.
Palestinian children in Jerusalem are served by Israeli hospitals and Palestinian hospitals. The Palestinian hospitals are currently being defunded by the US. US President Donald Trump has framed the funding cut as a way to pressure Palestinian negotiators to accede to policies of Israeli occupation.
US President Donald Trump ordered the State Department to withhold 25 million dollars earmarked as aid to Palestinian hospitals in Jerusalem in September 2018. Six Palestinian hospitals that constitute the East Jerusalem Hospital Network (EJHN) are the targets of the decision: the Makassed Islamic Charitable Hospital, Augusta Victoria Hospital, Red Crescent Maternity Hospital, St John’s Eye Hospital, Princess Basma Rehabilitation Centre and Saint Joseph’s Hospital.
Israeli authorities apply civilian criminal law to Palestinian children in Jerusalem, unlike Palestinian children in the West Bank, who are incarcerated as “security prisoners” under military law. Yet, Palestinian children in Jerusalem are in the constant presence of Israeli police and are subject to Israeli civilian criminal laws that target them for incarceration.
Activist in the al-Issawiya Local Committee Mohammad Abu Hummus adds: “The detention of children in Jerusalem is an ongoing policy. In recent weeks, many children were arrested in [al-Issawiya], such as Adam Abu Rayalla. He is 12 years old and was arrested at midnight”. During these arrests, Israeli forces violate the law and rights of Palestinian children by, for example, interrogating them without the presence of parents or a lawyer, denying family visitation, and even subjecting them to torture, as many said of the interrogation of 13 year old Ahmad Manasra.
Legal Council for the al-Quds Association Bassam al-Asad told the AIC: “recently there has been increasing rates of the arrest of children under 18 years old in Jerusalem. The rate of arrest of children is now much higher than in the past.”
Addameer : Prisoner Support and Human Rights Association reports that in 2017 Israeli police arrested a total of 1,138 Palestinian children in East Jerusalem, representing 17 percent of total arrests for the entire Palestinian population that year. Addameer emphasizes that in light of the fact that the Palestinian Jerusalem population reflects just 6 percent of the total Palestinian population in occupied territory, Jerusalemite children are arrested at disproportional rates.
The ‘Youth Bill,’ passed in November 2015, stipulates that Israeli forces are obliged to institute minimum sentences for children involved in stone throwing activities. It also rules that a child under 14 should be imprisoned for murder if she attempted the crime with “nationalist motives.”
The extension of administrative detainee status to children is another cause for action, a practice Israel recently revived the practice while arresting Palestinians for Facebook posts that allegedly “incite to violence.” Israeli law authorizes the use of administrative detention in Jerusalem, meaning indefinite imprisonment without trial or charge, based on “secret evidence” supplied by Israeli intelligence forces.
Occasionally, Israeli forces shoot and kill Palestinian children in Jerusalem. Usually, Israeli police claim after killing Palestinian children that they attempted to stab Israelis, as in the case of 16-year-old Fatima Abed al-Rahman Hajeiji.
Palestinians in East Jerusalem suffer from nationalist-religious Israeli colonial settlers who occasionally commit violence against Palestinians, including children, as a racist political statement. This environment is a daily source of anxiety for both Palestinian parents and children. The most notorious recent horror of this kind was the kidnapping and death of 16-year-old Mohammad Abu Khdeir in 2014. The three Israeli settlers kidnapped Abu Khdeir from his neighborhood in East Jerusalem and burned him to death.